Thought Provoking Question in Harry Potter! | Room of Requirement, Potions, Mirror of Erised, and more

The Potter Discussion: Harry Potter, Fantastic Beasts and the Wizarding World Fandom

Send us a text

In this episode, we discuss some very though provoking questions. Enjoy!
Topics/Summary:
· 2:00 What does the happiest person in the world see in the Mirror of Erised? Dumbledore claims they would see themselves exactly has as they are, but I don’t agree. Happiest doesn’t mean completely happy first of all, but also, there is a very little chance that there is a person in the world who really doesn’t want anything more. The only time it would be a mirror is when the person looking in it truly wanted to see a mirror image of themselves.

· 9:01 What are the limits of an animagus? The rules themselves have really never been defined, so could someone turn into air? We’ve seen switching spells work with air, so it could be possible. Also, humans are technically animals too, so could a person become an animagus of another person?

· 12:56 Possible ancient alien intervention = magic? There are many theories today about huge structures like the pyramids of Giza, but what if it is really magic in the wizarding world? That would make perfect sense. It is really the kind of canon that seems like it would be upheld by the author. It does make sense after all.

· 17:26 Why are some spells unforgivable and others completely allowed that can kill just the same? I could cast a spell that can explode a building and kill a hundred people and that certainly wouldn’t be allowed, but the casting of the spell wouldn’t be the offense. But with an unforgivable curse, it is the act of casting it that is horrible. Maybe that’s because of what it does to the caster, not the target. It is really personal and you really have to mean the spell when you cast it.

· 22:00 Why weren’t potions used in the Battle of Hogwarts? They were throwing crystal balls at the Death Eaters so the least they could do is throw a few potions as well. Why didn’t they? It could have been the short notice because Harry gave them a heads up just a few hours before the battle started, but shouldn’t they have been preparing weeks or months before Harry arrived?

· 26:40 Is there a magical creature that is considered close enough to human that they can occupy the Room of Requirement? There have certainly been magical creatures in the room at the same time, but what if it was a centaur? Is their intelligence enough to occupy it? But then what about a dragon? They are very intelligent, but would they do it?
Having anything you want to hear or say? Click here for a voice submission or here for text.
[email protected]
thepotterdiscussion.com
Nox

Capitole

1. Intro (00:00:00)

2. What does the happiest person in the world see in the Mirror of Erised (00:02:00)

3. What are the limits of an animagus (00:09:01)

4. Possible ancient alien intervention = magic (00:12:56)

5. Why are some spells unforgivable and others completely allowed that can kill just the same (00:17:26)

6. Why weren’t potions used in the Battle of Hogwarts (00:22:00)

7. Is there a magical creature that is considered close enough to human that they can occupy the Room of Requirement (00:26:40)